| Restaurants

Commander Cody’s Fish Shoppe

Home / Restaurants / Commander Cody’s Fish Shoppe



Commander Cody’s Fish Shoppe 631-749-1851 Corner of Smith Street and Midway Road Year-round fish market and dinners to go; outdoor summer dinner dining.

We rented a house at the end of June on Shelter Island and we fell in love with this beautiful getaway.

Of course we needed to eat at all of the yummy restaurants on the island and one of our favorites was, Commander Cody’s.

It is super tiny; about 10 tables all together. Usually the owner is frying chicken outside in fat filled frying pans.

Sometimes there is waiter service and sometimes there isn’t.

If you enter the kitchen, be prepared to be talked to.

Peaches usually works behind the raw bar and I have to say she is similar to Thai food, sweet and salty. That’s me and Peaches in the picture, on the top of this post:)

The daughter of the owner, who went to the CIA in Hyde Park, typically is cooking just about everything.

She is a great cook, yet a touch salty too:)

The raw bar is amazing, the ribs and fried chicken are off the hook.

The only fish I tried was the salmon. It was heavily seasoned and cooked perfectly.

The three times we went, fabulous Blues music was blasting.

Don’t forget to BYOB and remember to tell Peaches I said hello!